Showing posts with label ethnocentrism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ethnocentrism. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Youth in Qatar


One of our first readings, “Arab Youth, the Missing Demographic”, which focused on the large number of Arab youth and their identity struggles, complex relationships to media, and high unemployment rates, was something that I can relate to personally due to my involvement in the founding of The Youth Company. Before I explain what this company is, I also think what I am about to discuss relates closely to ideas of globalization and glocalization (customizations to better suit geographic areas) that we have previously discussed as well as hegemony, social construction, consumer cultures and ethnocentrism.
Almost two years ago a group of four friends and I sat down and decided to come up with a project that would shape and re-define the way the Qatari community views its youth. You may be wondering why I didn’t write about something more lighthearted, like the relations between the Arab dessert Umm Ali and British bread and butter pudding, or my thoughts on the “One Of Us” campaign here in Qatar, well it’s because The Youth Company is something that I feel everybody should know about because it genuinely relates to much of what we discuss in class and is something that we, as youth in this region, should be aware of.
We initially formed the company to be a way for youth from around Qatar to get to know each other and share thoughts about many social issues while working to remove any ethnocentric tendencies and foster notions of cultural relativism, however it quickly branched out and became a way for youth to gain different experiences in order to be more successful in the future. I’ll take a step back to explain briefly. In Qatar during high school, and even during university, it is very hard to acquire a part time job or even an internship, in order to gain experience that will help you in finding a job in the future. Unlike in many western countries, where during middle school you can work in a McDonalds or your dad’s car shop, there are limited activities here unless you model, work for Red Bull, or have very good connections or ‘wasta’ (it’s not what you know but who you know). Although this situation is improving each year, it used to be that in order to get the credits to get into a university, unless you were fortunate enough to play on a sports team or debate team, the most experience you were going to get was lax community and service work.
This is where the idea of The Youth Company (TYC) came from, now after two years of being fully functional I can quote our mission:
“Our youth work is informed by a set of beliefs that include a commitment to equal opportunities, and to young people as partners in learning and decision-making. We believe that the needs, abilities, and aspirations of young people should be recognized, understood, and met within a supportive environment, which encourages them to achieve their goals and make real measurable progress. We endeavour to value the whole person and not focus solely on the problems or difficulties that young people may present.”
This relates to our class discussions and readings as at TYC we have worked with Silatech and referenced the Silatech Index for many of our workshops and research conducted to determine how to best reach certain youth groups. As Qatar has such a multicultural and diverse population of youth, it becomes even more complex for the youth to have a say in society and have their voices heard when it comes to our rights. However, certain hegemonic views that ‘youth are just youth’ and the idea that we don’t accomplish much or contribute to society is greatly misinformed by society at large and unfortunately sometimes it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. The dominant group, being the rest of society, deems youth as being lazy and unaccomplished and instead of having youth just accept this as their fate, TYC works towards disbanding notions like this.
Due to society viewing youth in certain negative ways, many youth have moved online to social media to create large communities of active media consumers where youth can share thoughts openly without judging based on gender or ethnicity and without being judged by the rest of society. Examples of this can be seen on Facebook with pages and groups such as “What’s Goin on Qatar”, “Teenagers in Qatar”, and “Run The World Festival”. TYC actively participates with many of these groups, functioning mostly online, and is the creator of the Run The World Festival, which aims to bring together many youth sub-cultures in Qatar and allows them to learn from one another. This can be seen in last year’s RTWFestival where dance groups, singers, skateboarders, and different sports players were invited to perform and socialize at an event (side note: not many people even knew of the skater sub-culture in Qatar although it does exist).
Again relating to the reading, there is a 25% unemployment rate amongst Arab youth, and although that number may be lower in terms of Qatar, unemployment among youth is still something we see a lot of here. Despite having all of this American education and Western ways of living, in terms of globalization and glocalization, when it comes to how youth are perceived in society, it is still a very traditional outlook. The older generations have an older sense of looking at things and there are not many things for youth to do so they begin to look at these youth as miscreants – gangs of young people with too much time on their hands, and so starts the infamous “when I was your age” speech. Although I digress, my main point is that due to globalization, we have a mix of so many different cultures in Qatar’s youth population and a unique lifestyle where tradition meets many global concepts and forms of education, making it hard for us to relate to one another and to be heard and recognized in society. Therefore, companies like TYC work to bridge gaps in our youth community and also give different youth experiences that can help them later in life, which in a way can be viewed as social construction of our own youth culture.

Sunday, September 25, 2011

North Korea VS Qatar


The eye-opening documentary “A State of Mind” is centered on two North Korean gymnasts, Pak Hyon Sun and Kim Song Yun, who are preparing for the Pyongyang mass games, an annual event in NorthKorea. Throughout this documentary we not only see the ongoing struggles and challenges the girls face but also how their everyday life is, living in a communist run country that is extremely secluded from the rest of the world. After watching the documentary, the vast differences in culture between Qatar and North Korea were extremely apparent especially when it came to cultural diffusion, but regardless of North Korea’s ethnocentrism, some sociological similarities were visible as well.



The importance of family is a major one. Qataris and North Koreans share the same intense respect and love for family. For example we see Pak Hyon Sun is an only child living with her parents and grandparents under the same roof and Kim Song Yun is one of three girls in her family also living with their parents. Similarly, Qatari families have the same values when it comes to loved ones and express the same admiration towards elders. Mother daughter relationships in particular resemble each other in both cultures even in the smallest things, like mothers showing maternal affection and telling you to finish your food or go do your homework.


The mass games require an extreme amount of determination, skill and training especially in a sport as challenging as gymnastics however when compared to Qatar we see how similar that is with soccer in the region. Qatar has assembled a young team of athletes just over a decade before the event in hopes of reaching the impeccable standard it needs to win the world cup in 2022. This includes vigorous training sessions and ongoing will power, very much like what the two girls had to go through to be ready for the mass games.

The music and dancing portrayed in the documentary also shares the same essence as Qatar’s in that it’s very tradition oriented. During celebrations such as the mass games we hear patriotic music played by an orchestra and each dance or performance is telling a story. Qatar also has traditional dances and music originating from Bedouin times, in particular a sword dance called the Ardha, usually performed by men. Qatari music revolves largely around percussion and string instruments such as drums, violins and oud.

Qatar and North Korea are widely different from each other when it comes to most things, there’s no denying that. North Korea is definitely one of the more secretive countries in the world so their way of life might look strange to foreigners, but no matter how different a culture is to the other, there are certain aspects that they all have in common no matter how ethnocentric they are.

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Culture shock?

If someone would ask you, what makes you different from Person A or Person B, you would probably be able to come up with a list from the top of your head, without even having to think, like nationality, language, religion or even food habits or education.

In other words, the way you have been brought up is what differentiates you from the others. A sociologist defines this as culture. The way of life of people or more specifically, the human created strategies for adjusting to the environment.

For some of us, seeing different culture is the best part about traveling, where as for few other, they have a culture shock coming from place X to Y. Culture shock is the strain that people experience while traveling from one region to the other, and must reorient themselves to the ways of the new culture. And this was exactly what happened in the movie Outsourced, where an American products salesman (Todd) heads to India to because of his replacement, after his entire department is outsourced. Being unaware of the beliefs and values of India, he found himself in a very inconvenient situation. For example, in India, Cows are considered sacred and play an important role in the Hindu religion. Whereas when Todd goes to India, being ignorant, he talks about cows as a food product without realizing how sensitive a topic it was and he goes on doing the same sort of mistake, until he finally finds someone who could teach him about the Indian culture.

People’s behavior and values change from culture to culture, and that is rooted to the shortage and abundance of resources in different regions. For example, the video shows how common begging is in India. However, in Qatar it is hardly seen in public. The economic structure of the country breaks the conservation-oriented behaviors of its people.



According to Sociology, some of the most important types of non-material cultures are beliefs, values, norms, symbols and language. And some of these aspects were clearly noticeable in Culture Shock, an Al Jazeera documentary, on how African migrants find ways to deal with the European culture. These African migrants face instances of racist violence in Germany, where because of their skin color, people assign symbols. People assign offensive names.

Despite being immigrants, some of their habits perfectly match local customs, which is a case of cultural universals, which refers to things found in every culture. But sometimes people hold on to the viewpoint of ethnocentrism, because of which these African migrants are not being accepted by the social norms.

Click here to check out the documentary on Al Jazeera

Culture Shock: What is it like to live in Europe with an African identity?